Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch has accused Prime Minister Andy Burnham of wanting the "vibes" of welfare reform without actually reducing Britain's rising benefits bill. The accusation came during a heated exchange at Prime Minister's Questions, where Badenoch argued that plans announced this week to reduce welfare payments for some young people did not go far enough.
The clash follows a major review by former cabinet minister Alan Milburn, which proposed sweeping changes to help those aged 16 to 25 who are not in education, employment or training (Neet) get back into work. The report included plans for welfare cuts that could see some young people have their benefits reduced.
Conservatives Criticise Report's Scope
The Conservatives argued that the "lion's share" of the recommendations would mean a "massive spending plan" and a "massive expansion of the role of government." Badenoch said: "What he wants is the vibes of welfare reform without actually doing any welfare reform. We need to bring down the welfare bill because we cannot afford it."
Badenoch stated that working-age welfare is costing £180 billion a year, a figure due to rise to £220 billion. She added that the Prime Minister and Mr Milburn appeared to be at odds over whether some young people will receive less in benefits.
PM Defends Approach
Mr Burnham insisted that he "will do everything that I can as quickly as possible to get the welfare bill down." However, he avoided committing to reducing costs before the end of this parliament, expected to close in 2029.
Mr Burnham responded: "We are about helping young people into work, we are about giving young people hope and a better life – that is what this whole reform is about." He continued: "There needs to be some humility from the party opposite. They left government with almost one million young people without any hope for their future – we want to give them a better life. Yes, we do want people to accept the support that's on offer – and that is clear – and that is in the report. But we will not accept, time and again, [Ms Badenoch] coming to this House saying that we are going to bring down the welfare bill, but fail to support our young people."
Youth Guarantee Scheme Criticised
Ms Badenoch accused the Prime Minister of offering young people "false hope." She said: "He keeps talking about all of the Government schemes that they've got. The youth guarantee scheme is a complete and total failure. Everyone out there knows it. They destroy jobs, they kill businesses and then they offer the businesses a little money to give young people work placements. It makes no sense at all."
Responding, Mr Burnham said: "The fundamentals of the British economy are strong and they are getting stronger. We will consider the Milburn report in the round, and we will look at all of its proposals in detail, and we will bring forward our response. But if she is arguing here for a cuts-only approach, well, we will stand against that because we know that will not help a generation move on."