Starmer and Reeves Policies Still Damaging Youth, Report Says
Starmer, Reeves Policies Still Damaging Youth: Report

A government-commissioned study into youth unemployment concludes that policies pursued under Keir Starmer and Rachel Reeves continue to cause significant damage today, robbing thousands of young people of opportunities. The report, authored by former Labour politician Alan Milburn, highlights that nearly a million people aged 16 to 24 are not in education, employment or training (NEETs).

National Insurance Changes Hit Recruitment

Milburn examined the impact of Reeves' decision to increase employer National Insurance contributions, a change that came into effect in 2025. He found it had stopped employers from giving jobs to young people.

He said: "I have looked carefully at employer National Insurance. Employers have consistently told me that higher payroll costs have made recruitment more difficult, particularly in sectors such as retail and hospitality where margins are tight and young people make up a significant part of the workforce."

Government changes "increased the cost of a full-time worker on the National Living Wage by around £800 per year," he said. They cost employers £25.7 billion every year "directly from the bottom line of businesses" and have had a "negative impact on business sentiment".

Employment Rights Act Concerns

Milburn also addressed the impact of Labour's Employment Rights Act, designed to give workers more rights from the start of a new job and make it harder to use zero-hours contracts without set hours.

He said: "The Employment Rights Act 2025 introduces guaranteed-hours and related provisions, with important implementation detail still to be settled. It has been the subject of many concerns raised with me by employers."

He added: "I have heard a powerful argument that too much regulation here will deter employers from employing more young people by limiting employers' ability to flex hours and conditions."

While trade unions welcomed giving workers more rights, Milburn concluded: "The potential impact is already being felt with more than a third (37 per cent) of employers planning to reduce permanent hiring because of Employment Right Act reforms."

Benefits System Failing Young People

Milburn also argued the Government needs to change the benefits system to help young people into work. He warned that the number of young people receiving incapacity benefits has more than doubled since 2012, to approximately 250,000. In 10 years' time, 820,000 young people are likely to be receiving Personal Independence Allowance (PIP) - one in nine of all young people in the UK.

While the Government "writes a cheque", it does not do enough to help these young people off benefits and into work, he said. Last year, the Government attempted to cut the numbers receiving PIP but backed down after a rebellion by Labour backbench MPs. Milburn says most of the blame lies with the government of the day, because Ministers only spoke about the money they would save, not the help people would receive.

In an interview with Andrew Marr for LBC, he said: "I think in the end the buck stops with the person in charge, doesn't it? And the person in charge was Keir. And look, I think it was the wrong judgement. And the truth is, at that moment, that's when his premiership effectively came to an end, because his authority went, and Labour MPs were thinking for the first time, actually, this is the wrong direction, not the right direction."

Milburn argues the money should instead be spent on training and mental health support, which would eventually mean taxpayers spent less, while young people could look forward to a life earning a living. Andy Burnham insisted this morning it was unfair to blame Rachel Reeves, but the report makes clear the harm inflicted is still causing pain and misery today.