Labour MP Jess Phillips has said a new Online Safety Act is likely needed to deal with convicted criminals such as Russell Brand using social media to broadcast messages from prison. Her comments follow Google's rejection of a UK government request to remove a video in which Brand denies the sexual offences for which he was convicted.
Google rejects request to remove Brand video
Days after Brand's conviction, his wife, Laura, broadcast a message from her husband to their 6.6 million YouTube subscribers claiming he was not guilty of the sexual offences for which a jury convicted him. The video has almost 850,000 views.
The Ministry of Justice launched an investigation into whether Brand broke prison rules. Google, which owns YouTube, rejected the UK government's request, made via the Prison Service, to take the video down amid warnings it was causing distress to sexual abuse survivors.
Government lacks power to compel removal
A Google spokesperson said: "We're aware of the new content and our teams are investigating. We suspended Russell Brand's channel from the YouTube partner program in September 2023. The channel has not been able to monetise on YouTube since then."
Phillips, a former minister for safeguarding and violence against women and girls, admitted the government does not have the power to compel platforms to remove such distressing content. She told BBC Radio 4's Today programme that Ofcom codes on women's safety online are voluntary, adding: "This is an entirely new era and frankly the regulations are almost certainly not in place for the government to just demand that this be taken down."
Calls for action and potential new legislation
The Online Safety Act, passed in 2023, protects users from illegal content and ensures under-18s are not exposed to age-inappropriate material. It does not explicitly address prisoners using social media to communicate with the outside world, which Phillips said is not sufficient. She said: "Regulatory frameworks, changes and potentially a second online safety act is needed, because before we haven't had prisoners who had massive YouTube followings."
Phillips said pressure would continue to build on organisations like Google, adding: "All Google do by leaving this up is show that those codes are not good enough... If Google want less regulation they will take this down."
Ministers joined calls for action on Thursday morning, alongside the victims' commissioner for London, Andrea Simon. Josh MacAlister, minister for children and families, said he hoped Google would make the same decision as Meta, which disabled Brand's accounts for breaching standards prohibiting content "harmful to the community". Housing minister Matthew Pennycook told Sky News the video was "quite disturbing" and "abhorrent in the message it's conveying", noting that prisoners are already banned from making statements to the media.
Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch said she was concerned if prisoners could use conduits in prison to send messages, but felt Brand's wife was a separate person and YouTube was "a private platform". She said: "Immediately demanding that private platforms take down without looking at whether a law has been broken is not where I would start from."