Burnham censorship row over 'trustworthy' news feed plans
Burnham censorship row over 'trustworthy' news feed plans

Andy Burnham has sparked a censorship row over plans campaigners warn could let the Government pick the news you see on your phone.

Ministers are said to be exploring options to force social media giants to push content from public service broadcasters such as the BBC and ITV higher up people's feeds. Critics warn the plans would see certain outlets branded "trustworthy", handing Whitehall extraordinary sway over what the public reads. It is not yet clear who would decide which outlets qualify.

MP warns of 'Orwellian undertones'

Tory MP Nigel Huddleston said the proposals had "alarming Orwellian undertones" and risked creating "a system of government-approved media, which would align Britain with some of the most authoritarian states on the planet".

Writing for the Daily Express, he warned the plans could even end up regulating newspapers on social media, "adding new regulations to the likes of the Daily Express". He revealed he had asked Ofcom's chief executive in Parliament how she would define "trustworthy" news, and that "she could not provide a clear-cut answer".

Citing reports of civil servants working as fact-checkers for broadcasters, he asked: "Is this the future, where government mandarins are roaming newsrooms looking over the shoulders of journalists checking that their work is trustworthy and meets government standards?"

Plans set out in Media Green Paper

The plans, set out in the Government's Media Green Paper, are justified by ministers as a way to prop up broadcasters through the decline of traditional TV, and to tackle misinformation.

Jack Coulson, of Big Brother Watch, branded the proposals an "algorithmic land-grab" that was "bad in practice and worse in principle". He said platforms such as Instagram, and possibly YouTube, could be made to rig their algorithms in favour of approved outlets, with everyone else pushed down people's feeds.

Mr Coulson said: "Being branded 'trustworthy' by the Government is rather like being the friend your parents describe as 'a good influence': true or not, it's a quick way to make everyone wonder whose side you're on."

But Mr Coulson argued research shows false information online is mainly consumed by a small minority who actively seek it out, and who are the "last people" likely to change their minds because "a bit more Channel 4 is shoved into their feeds". He said: "We believe you can be trusted to decide what news you see."

He warned it was paternalistic for ministers to "'protect' us weak-minded members of the public from information and ideas of which ministers disapprove".

Newspapers and former minister alarmed

The plans have also alarmed Britain's newspapers. The News Media Association, which represents publishers including the Daily Express, warned that "the path of least resistance for platforms is to promote public service broadcaster content, transferring visibility and revenue from the commercial press".

Former Culture Secretary Sir John Whittingdale branded the proposals "a very dangerous extension of Government interference in the freedom of the press and the right to free speech".

Big Brother Watch insists it is no fan of Big Tech either, arguing that if ministers want to rein in the platforms, they should hand control to users. Mr Coulson said: "If someone wants a feed full of PSM content, or none at all, that's their business, not the Government's."

The Department for Culture, Media and Sport has been approached for comment.