Ex-Tory Andrew Boff warns party has become 'authoritarian' under Badenoch
Ex-Tory Andrew Boff warns party 'authoritarian' under Badenoch

Andrew Boff, a veteran London Assembly Member who resigned from the Conservative Party last month after 53 years of membership, has claimed the party has changed beyond recognition under Kemi Badenoch's leadership.

Mr Boff said he was blocked from standing as the party's Mayoral candidate because of his support for the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR). This ran contrary to the stance of Tory leader Ms Badenoch, who announced last year that anyone wishing to stand as a Conservative candidate must back her pledge to leave the convention.

ECHR Pledge as 'Purity Test'

Ms Badenoch's initial stance only referred to Parliamentary candidates, with Mr Boff questioning why anyone running for City Hall would need to sign up to the same decree.

"It's going to be a purity test going forward – it makes me wonder whether or not they're going to apply that to every single candidate who stands for every position," he told the Local Democracy Reporting Service (LDRS). "The effect of that would be to say that any Conservative candidate wants to reduce your human rights. Now, that's an outrageous thing to fight an election on."

The ECHR is an international treaty adopted in 1950 by the Council of Europe, intended to protect human rights and fundamental freedoms across member states. It has been a central part of UK law, though critics, including Ms Badenoch, have claimed it thwarts governmental efforts to deal with illegal migration and deport foreign criminals.

Churchill's Legacy and Party Shift

Mr Boff noted that the convention was supported by Winston Churchill at the time. "It was fought for by British lawyers and British Members of Parliament to establish minimum human rights – and being in the Conservative Party, that's something I believe in – individual rights," he said.

"It's been adhered to by 46 nation states since then – the only people who've pulled out of the ECHR is Putin's Russia. And yet, we are now following suit. I don't think that's a Conservative trait at all. I haven't changed. The Andrew Boff who stood for election in 2004 hasn't changed one iota. What has changed is the position of the Conservative Party, which has become really quite authoritarian."

Mr Boff was always seen as a political maverick by colleagues, one who didn't necessarily toe the party line at all times. This played out at the party's annual conference in 2023, when he was dragged out of the main hall by security after heckling then-Home Secretary Suella Braverman, now a senior Reform MP.

Resignation and Future Plans

Mr Boff said he was happy to remain in the Tories even if disagreements with the leadership over the ECHR continued, but being blocked from standing was the final straw. The news broke suddenly on a Tuesday evening in late October, catching even his own former party colleagues by surprise.

"It's one of those easy, difficult decisions that you have in life, which is it's a difficult decision because of the implications that it's going to have, and it's had loads of implications. But it was easy because they crossed a line," he said. "I resigned on the spot. I had no intention of doing so that morning. [But] as soon as they explained to me why I was not allowed to enter into the process, they were very clear that it was my support for human rights."

However, he claims he is open to returning should CCHQ change their stance on the ECHR. Should Ms Badenoch, or any future leader, not change the "purity test", Mr Boff said he will run for another term on the London Assembly as an independent.

For now, he doesn't expect many colleagues to follow, and instead will pursue his personal priorities in City Hall, including devolution, building more family housing, avoiding construction on the Green Belt, and opposing plans to pedestrianise more of Oxford Street. He won't bow to demands from some party colleagues to stand down and call a by-election either. Emma Best, Deputy Leader of the City Hall Conservatives, claimed it was the right thing to do, since he was elected on a Tory ticket.

Susan Hall, leader of the group, took a different stance. She said: "Andrew has been a forthright and vocal supporter of Conservative principles, and we thank him for his contribution to our party. Despite this, we stand resolutely by the party's commitment to leaving the ECHR, and believe fully that the rights and privileges that we enjoy in this country can be maintained without the need for a foreign court. We will continue to support this policy."