UK and Ireland pledge co-operation on Northern Ireland Troubles legacy
UK and Ireland pledge NI Troubles legacy co-operation

The UK and Irish Governments have pledged to co-operate on dealing with the legacy of Northern Ireland's troubled past, following a meeting of the British-Irish Intergovernmental Conference (BIIGC) in Dublin.

Irish Foreign Affairs Minister Helen McEntee hailed a positive relationship, but confirmed that Ireland's interstate case against the UK at the European Court of Human Rights will remain in place while the controversial 2023 Legacy Act remains in law.

Legacy Focus of Dublin Meeting

Legacy was a significant focus of the BIIGC meeting at Iveagh House on Thursday, attended by Northern Ireland Secretary Sir Chris Bryant, Ms McEntee, and Irish Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan.

The ministers discussed progress on implementing the two governments' Joint Framework on legacy, including the progress of legislation in Westminster and the Oireachtas. Swift implementation, including reciprocal co-operation to build public confidence in legacy arrangements in both jurisdictions, was also discussed.

Sir Chris described the governments as being “completely and utterly aligned” on legacy. He said: “We all want to make sure that families and victims themselves get the answers that they really, really need.”

Interstate Case Remains

Sir Chris revealed he raised the question of the Irish Government dropping its interstate case against the UK, saying in the press conference after the meeting: “I would urge you to do so again, I don't think it's necessary.”

“We believe that our Legacy Commission will be fully human rights compliant, and we're not going to be undermining any element of the framework, so I hope that we'll be able to get to that,” he said.

Ms McEntee responded that the 2023 legislation which prompted the action is still in place. “While I have every confidence, and we're working closely with, particularly following the framework that was agreed last September, we are working together, both Governments, to make sure that new legislation is enacted,” she said.

“We hope by the spring that will replace the 2023 legislation, but that is still the law, and until that changes, obviously the case will stay as it is.” She added: “I hope I've been very clear with our colleagues that we do intend to remove that case. However, while the current legislation is still law, there is a challenge there.”

Co-operation on New Legislation

Ms McEntee described a “huge amount of work” having gone into agreeing the framework last September by their predecessors. She said: “It's really important that on both islands we have legislation introduced as quickly as possible, so that we can move to the next stage, and most importantly, for victims and survivors and their families, that they find truth and accountability.”

“And that is front and centre of everything that we do, and so we will continue to work together and to co-operate with each other in that regard,” she added.

Meanwhile, Mr O'Callaghan took issue with comments made by the head of the Legacy Commission, Sir Declan Morgan, criticising the Irish authorities in terms of co-operation. In June, it was contended that the commission had written to the Garda on eight occasions to request information on cases that, in total, involve 10 murders and had yet to receive any replies.

Mr O'Callaghan responded on Thursday saying he was surprised by Sir Declan's comments. “I was surprised at them, and I disagree with them,” he said. “It is important that we have in place a statutory body that is fully compliant with all human rights obligations. That will happen once the new legislation is enacted. I have checked with An Garda Síochána in respect of some of the criticisms raised by Sir Declan, and I don't believe they have substance.”