SNP denies youth unemployment crisis as Labour warns of catastrophe
SNP denies youth unemployment crisis as Labour warns of catastrophe

Scottish Labour has warned that failing to tackle the rising number of young Scots on benefits would be a "moral failure and economic catastrophe", as the SNP denied there is a crisis.

Melanie Ward, MP for Cowdenbeath and Kirkcaldy and a Scotland Office minister, welcomed the recommendations of the Milburn review, which examined how to help the one million people across the UK aged 16 to 24 who are not in education, employment or training (NEET). The landmark report proposes moving young people off the two main sickness and disability benefits and on to a new system.

Milburn Review Recommendations

Alan Milburn, a former Labour health secretary, made clear he believed the underlying principles of his recommendations "should be applied across the UK". The review sets out a route into work for young people, with earlier support and real opportunities, and a clear expectation that young people take them up.

Ward said the "scale of the crisis is shocking" and called for action to "get the benefits bill down for good". Writing for the Record, she said: "Our young people are brilliant. They deserve the chance to reach their full potential in life."

SNP Response

Mairi McAllan, the SNP education secretary, dismissed the year-long review as "not a report for Scotland about Scotland" and denied the country's soaring benefits bill was unsustainable in the long term. The Nationalist minister also repeatedly refused to say if she even believed there is a NEETs crisis in Scotland – and said she doesn't like using the term NEET because it is a "label".

John Swinney yesterday said the SNP Government would take time to consider the Milburn review and its recommendations.

Economic Impact

Ward said: "But in Scotland today, too many are missing the essential building blocks. They are let down by failing systems and held back by structural barriers. The scale of the crisis is shocking. Around one in six young people are not in work, education or training."

She added: "That means lost wages, lost confidence and lost opportunities, with the effects felt in households, communities and the economy for years to come. Being out of work at the start of adult life can leave scars that never fully heal, and only a 50 per cent chance that you will ever come off benefits."

Ward continued: "Alan Milburn's diagnosis is clear. Many young people are trapped in what he calls a ‘rejection economy’. They cannot get a job without experience, but they cannot get experience without someone giving them a first chance. Analysis shows the reforms could lift 50,000 people out of poverty in the next decade."

She said: "The Tories want us to make crude cuts. We will not take that path; our UK Labour government ended austerity, and we are proud to have done so. Instead, we will shift government support to invest in success, rather than continuing to pay for failure through the benefits system. There will be new opportunities and guaranteed local routes into work, which young people will be expected to take up when they can."

Ward concluded: "Opportunity matched by responsibility. That is how we bring back hope, build a more preventative and productive country, and get the benefits bill down for good."