Scotland's council tax system is under renewed pressure to be scrapped, 20 years after the SNP first promised to reform it. The Scottish Greens are set to hold a debate at the Scottish Parliament on the issue, and have warned First Minister John Swinney that they may not support his plans to reform local authorities without a clear commitment to abolish council tax first.
The SNP was first elected to Holyrood in 2007 on a manifesto that included a commitment to reform the system for funding local government, which is still largely based on property prices valued in 1991.
Union calls for urgent action
Scotland's most senior trade unionist has added her voice to the calls, urging the SNP Government to cut councils free from a "tax system that is fundamentally unfit for purpose". Roz Foyer, STUC general secretary, said: "For far too long, local government has been shackled to a tax system that is fundamentally unfit for purpose. It fails to raise the resources our places need to sustain decent public services, leaves a growing hole in local government finances and entrenches managed decline in our communities."
Foyer added: "It simply doesn’t have to be this way - STUC research has shown that a proportionate property tax on residential homes in Scotland could raise almost £1 billion for the public coffers. If politicians are serious about local government reform and delivering better public services, then tinkering around the edges simply won't cut it."
She said: "Scotland’s workers have had enough of false political promises that duck the difficult decisions and kick meaningful reform of our council tax system into the long grass. The Scottish Greens deserve credit for pushing this issue up the political agenda and we need those parties that position themselves as progressive to work together to address decades of failure and secure the fairer, more progressive reform of local government taxation we need."
Campaigners and Greens weigh in
Lisa Hough-Stewart of the Tax Justice Scotland campaign said: "Scotland cannot build a fairer society on an unfair tax system. If the Scottish Government are serious about tackling local government reform, strengthening public services and delivering a greener, more caring future, it must be prepared to confront the fundamental injustices in how wealth is taxed, starting with the long-overdue reform of council tax."
She added: "Standing still is a political choice and one that comes at a cost to public services, communities and working people. Politicians cannot keep promising a fairer future while clinging to a broken model of local government taxation and the Scottish Government must show the political leadership needed to replace this fundamentally regressive system."
Ross Greer, Scottish Greens co-leader, said: "John Swinney has big plans to reform local councils, but he can’t just redraw the map and leave a broken funding system in place. The Scottish Greens can work with the government on this agenda - but only if the plans include replacing the broken council tax."
Greer added: "This is a once-in-a-generation opportunity to fix how we fund our schools, social care and other local services. I hope that MSPs will support this Green proposal and seize the opportunity to finally scrap and replace the council tax once and for all."