Waste management firm Biffa has told an appeal court that a judge “erred in law” when he dismissed its £50 million compensation claim over Scotland's failed deposit return scheme (DRS).
Biffa had been seeking £51.4 million from the Scottish Government to cover losses it said it incurred when the scheme was shelved. In January 2026, judge Lord Sandison found against the firm, ruling that its case “fails in fact and law”.
Background of the dispute
The dispute centres on a letter sent in May 2022 by former Scottish Green co-leader Lorna Slater, who was the minister in charge of the project. Biffa argued the letter contained a “negligent misrepresentation” that provided assurances about the scheme's viability, while failing to mention that the Scottish Government would need an exemption from the Internal Market Act (IMA) for the scheme to proceed.
The IMA governs trade between different parts of the UK post-Brexit. Then Scottish Secretary Alister Jack refused to grant the exemption, which prevented Holyrood ministers from including glass bottles in the scheme and ultimately left them unable to bring it in as planned in August 2023.
Appeal arguments
At the Court of Session on Wednesday, Biffa's lawyers said they did not dispute Lord Sandison's factual findings but argued he erred in his analysis. Andrew McWhirter opened submissions, telling the court: “The commercial judge erred in law in his conclusion that the letter of May 17 2022 was not a negligent misrepresentation.”
Biffa's lead counsel, Roddy Dunlop KC, said Ms Slater's letter was “accurate” but a “half-truth” because it failed to mention something ministers knew could have scuppered the DRS. He argued that by assuring Biffa of commitment to delivering the scheme by August 16 2023, there was an implied representation that ministers knew of no matter preventing that, yet they knew an IMA exclusion was needed but not sought.
Lord Pentland suggested the letter was merely stating a political commitment. Mr Dunlop responded that it was written to persuade Biffa to enter the contract, adding: “There was no obligation on the ministers to write that letter. Having chosen to do so, there are consequences that follow if it creates a misleading impression.”
Next steps
Mr Dunlop said that by sending a letter of “comfort” to Biffa, knowing the firm would be exposed to an “eight-figure loss”, the Scottish Government assumed responsibility, which should have led to disclosure of the need for an IMA exclusion. He closed by urging the judges to uphold the appeal, stating: “If this court corrects those errors of law, the (factual) findings do the rest.”
Lawyers for the Scottish ministers are due to make submissions after the lunch break. The hearing before Lady Wick, Lord Pentland and Lord Ericht continues.