American filmmaker Hopwood DePree has lodged an appeal against a High Court ruling that dismissed his claim against Rochdale council over the future of Hopwood Hall in Middleton.
The move follows a two-day hearing at Manchester’s Civil Justice Centre in September, where His Honour Judge Hodge KC ruled in favour of the council. Mr DePree claimed the town hall acted unlawfully by denying what he described as a ‘legally binding’ option to buy the Grade-II*-listed building.
Background to the dispute
The dispute centres on an ‘options agreement’ originally signed in 2017, which gave Mr DePree the option to buy the hall for a ‘peppercorn fee’ of £1 if he produced a viable plan to restore the building. The agreement was torn up by the council in October 2024.
The council argued there was a lack of progress in enacting the agreement, despite granting planning permission for the hall’s change of use in 2022. Judge Hodge KC said the planning application did not cover the whole of the property – or demonstrate the ability to reinstate and refurbish Hopwood Hall, as required by the agreement.
He added: “I am satisfied, for the reasons I have given, that the planning permission does not satisfy the requirements of the options agreement. I therefore refuse to grant the relief sought by the claimant.”
Appeal lodged before deadline
Mr DePree was ordered to pay £114,000 in costs and was given until November 18 to appeal the ruling. Following an open letter to council leader Neil Emmott, he said he had hoped for a resolution outside court, but has now filed an appeal.
In a statement, Mr DePree said: “Following my open letter to the leader of Rochdale council, I was genuinely hopeful that we could meet promptly and find an amicable way forward that would allow my team and me to resume our rescue of Hopwood Hall.
“Sadly, our lawyers were informed that a meeting would not be taking place, leaving us with little choice but to file our application for permission to appeal before the November 18 deadline.
“It is incredibly disappointing. Every pound being spent on legal proceedings is money that could be so much better spent saving this extraordinary historic building.
“The community has been locked out for more than two years, and it seems Hopwood Hall is once again sitting dark and desolate.
“There are also important questions raised in my open letter that remain unanswered, including decisions taken over many years that have contributed to the hall’s decline and the loss of community access to this remarkable piece of our shared heritage.
“I still believe there is an opportunity to put things right, and I would much rather be sitting around a table discussing solutions than spending time and money in court.
“But sometimes, when something is not right, you have to stand up for it. That is what we are doing, and I sincerely hope we can still find a positive way forward for Hopwood Hall and the community.”
Council response
A spokesperson for Rochdale council said: “The council successfully defended the High Court proceedings concerning Hopwood Hall, with the claim dismissed and judgement given in the council’s favour. The court also ordered the claimant to pay the council’s legal costs.
“An application for permission to appeal has been lodged but the next step is for the court to determine whether permission to appeal should be granted. Given that the legal process remains ongoing, it would not be appropriate to comment further on the proceedings.
“Our focus remains on securing a sustainable long-term future for Hopwood Hall for the benefit of the wider community.”