An Irvine second-hand car dealer has been allowed to renew his licence despite a customer's complaint about a vehicle he bought after an MOT. The decision was made at a meeting of North Ayrshire Licensing Board last Wednesday.
Dealer's Account of the Sale
Colin Macdonald, who runs Irvine Car Centre on East Road, said he had never received an objection in 36 years of trading. He explained that on March 12, customer Tom Dawson purchased an 11-year-old Nissan Qashqai, and the car was taken to an independent MOT station on March 17 because the dealership does not carry out MOTs.
The car failed on suspension arms, dropped light bulbs and wiper blades. Jamiesons carried out the repairs and re-tested the car, which passed with no advisories. Mr Dawson collected the car on March 20.
Customer's Complaint
Mr Dawson said his objection was based on the quality of the vehicle and the post-sale service, and that his rights under the Consumer Rights Act 2015 were ignored. He said he was surprised the car passed with no advisories after asking Irvine Car Centre to inspect it, a request he claimed was ignored.
He hired an independent inspector who identified several additional issues with the car, which in their expert opinion existed before the sale. Mr Dawson said the car had multiple faults, including issues with the tyres, and had been taken off the road as it was not fit for purpose.
Licence Renewal Granted
Mr Macdonald said he was not liable for a broken coil spring, which he said would cost only £30 to repair, because three months had passed since the work was done and Trading Standards had advised him of this. He said the MOT had no mention of any corrosion.
Licensing Committee chair Collier said both sides had been considered, but the salient point was the 30-day period advised and confirmed by Trading Standards. She said Mr Dawson's continued unhappiness with the car was a civil matter and not relevant to the licence.
The renewal was granted, with the chair noting this was Mr Macdonald's first appearance before the committee. She warned that if similar matters arose, he could come before the committee again. Councillor Christina Larsen proposed granting the licence, seconded by councillor Ronnie Stalker.