Europe minister Hamish Falconer has been mocked on social media after a video suggested that food produced in Britain has become more expensive because of Brexit import rules. The clip, posted on X, shows Mr Falconer placing milk, beef mince, eggs and broccoli into a supermarket basket while explaining that the quantity of forms required for goods to enter the country adds costs to items sold in British supermarkets.
Critics point to British produce
Critics quickly noted that all the items in the minister's basket were produced in Britain and would not be affected by import paperwork. Tory shadow environment secretary Victoria Atkins responded: "Maybe check the packaging next time. The produce in the basket is British and hasn't come from the EU. Oh, and our food prices are lower than in the EU (ONS and Eurostat) but enjoy the milk."
Broadcaster Andrew Neil said: "No idea who this guy is (Labour MP/Minister?) but he's an idiot. Just about everything he puts in his basket is British food so not subject to import rules/paperwork. Why would their prices fall after so-called 'reset'? More likely to rise since under the 'reset' all food must conform to expensive EU regs, even food just for domestic market."
Economist calls comments 'gibberish'
Economist Julian Jessop accused Mr Falconer of talking "gibberish", adding: "The main drivers of higher food prices are global or otherwise unrelated to Brexit, such as government policies on labour costs, energy, and tax. The UK-EU 'reset' will not lower food prices. Exporting more food to the EU will not reduce prices at home."
Mr Jessop also said the UK can already reduce barriers to allow cheaper imports from the EU and, thanks to Brexit, from the rest of the world. He argued that the agri-food deal would impose additional costs on all businesses, not just those trading with the EU, and that other aspects of the "reset" would raise costs across the whole economy, notably by increasing the cost of energy and requiring the UK to impose the EU's higher tariffs on a range of other goods.
Government defends the deal
The video comes as the Prime Minister is set to strike a food and agriculture deal with the bloc at a joint summit, along with pacts on emissions trading and youth mobility. Mr Falconer added that the food deal Andy Burnham is set to sign with the EU on Friday would "reduce the cost" of his goods.
A Government spokesman said: "As the minister clearly states in the video, our food and drink deal with the EU will cut paperwork and costs for exporters, including British farmers exporting meat. In fact, UK farmers are currently barred from exporting mince meat into the EU at all. Our deal will end that."