Desire Under the Elms review: Committed but overwrought at the Almeida
Desire Under the Elms: Committed but overwrought at Almeida

Eugene O’Neill’s 1924 play about rural greed and incest, inspired by the Greek tragedy of Phaedra’s fatal love for her stepson, operates at a high pitch of emotional intensity throughout. In this rare and highly stylised London revival at the Almeida, director Ebenezer Bamgboye takes things to another level, throwing music, poetry, writhing choreography, expressionist lighting changes and the racial politics of the Deep South into the mix. The cast, particularly Kelly Gough as the stepmother Abbie, leave everything on stage. While the production confirms Bamgboye’s flair for dramatic staging – he was nominated for the Standard’s 2025 Emerging Talent theatre award – it is frankly overwrought and exhausting.

A Shift in Setting and Cast

The action has been moved from the 1850s to the early 20th century and from New England to somewhere below the Mason-Dixon line. On a hardscrabble farm, three brothers bemoan their lot, toiling endlessly for their dictatorial, messianically entitled father Ephraim, as unyielding as the stones that blight the land. In Bamgboye’s version, the elder two, sired on Ephraim’s first wife, are white. The third, Eben (Zackary Momoh), born to a second spouse whose family owned the farmland and who the paterfamilias worked into the ground, is black. This somewhat subverts a late revelation in the text.

Ephraim (Antony Byrne) has left the farm for the first time in 30 years and surprisingly returns with a third wife, Gough’s Abbie, making the issue of inheritance even more fraught. Especially when it becomes clear the mutual hatred between Abbie and Eben conceals something more transgressive. In a production where everyone operates at full pitch throughout, Gough’s spiderish Abbie, Momoh’s volcanically seething Eben and Byrne’s firebrand, bristle-bearded Ephraim go up to 11.

Ritual and Symbolism

The production is laden with ritual and symbolism from the start. The stage, dressed by designer Basia Bińkowska, is a sacrificial oblong with a huge, underused screen behind and a mysterious pail suspended above, the significance of which is paid off at the very end. Eben paces the bounds, buffing the boards with spit and polish, his ever-present dishrag a sign that he’s been relegated to “women’s work” after his mother’s death. At emotional flashpoints, he sprints circuits through the audience.

Abbie’s arrival is a further emasculation: she threatens not once but twice to castrate him. Her body language is exaggerated, sometimes recalling a zoological rehearsal exercise that’s been kept in, and her scenes with Eben become frantic pas de deux in which they paw at each other. Gough’s performance is outsized but mesmerising, too big and bold to take your eyes off.

An Ominous Chorus and a Relentless End

Three black “spirits” – singer Choolwe Laina Muntanga, guitarist Tendai Humphrey Sitima and trumpeter Nathaniel Wade – drift around the action in the first half like an ominous chorus, adding haunting sung passages and sudden musical stings to underscore moments of stress. In the second, they’re recast as guests celebrating the birth of a new son and then menacing watchers of the unfolding tragedy: music is largely abandoned in favour of oblique passages of recorded poetry. Towards the mercilessly inevitable end, bars of light blaze across the back screen, like the high beams of an oncoming truck.

O’Neill and Tennessee Williams, whose careers overlapped during the great flowering of 20th century American drama, build plots like steamrollers then drive them grindingly back and forth over their variously doomed characters. Both have had their works rejuvenated in recent years at the Almeida in productions by Rebecca Frecknall that lifted them out of the realms of realism or even melodrama. Frecknall has been a mentor to Bamgboye and one can see the imprint of her work in the strong visuals, pregnant atmosphere and elevated emotional pitch here. The central trio and the “spirits” give exceptional performances within the production’s framework. But it’s too strong, too relentless and – running at almost three hours – too long. More modulation next time, please. Runs to 23 Dec at Almeida.co.uk.