GMB star Narinder Kaur in tense welfare row over pensioners
Narinder Kaur in tense welfare row over pensioners

Matthew Allwright was forced to intervene after guests Narinder Kaur and Marc Goldfinger clashed on the Jeremy Vine show over whether the government should reduce public spending on pensioners to help younger generations secure work.

Clash over welfare spending

During the debate on Alan Milburn's review of the UK's youth unemployment crisis, Kaur said she was tired of welfare spending being seen as an attack on pensioners, noting that poorer pensioners do need protecting. She pointed out that 55% of the welfare bill is spent on pensioners, with billions going on the triple lock pension.

Kaur, a Good Morning Britain panellist, argued that rich pensioners in mortgage-free homes are receiving welfare while working-age people pay into the system and younger generations struggle to find work or get on the property ladder. She expressed concern for her own children, aged 19 and 20, saying she is worried sick about how they will get on the property and find work.

Goldfinger hits back

Conservative Councillor Goldfinger responded by asking whether Kaur was suggesting taking money away from someone's grandmother to get a 19-year-old into work. He argued that people have been paying into the system their entire working lives and that the government is spending 25 times more on welfare for young people.

When Kaur asked if rich people should receive welfare, Goldfinger said that was not the question, adding that pensioners receive £12,500 a year, which he described as not luxury. Kaur countered that it is luxury for a rich pensioner.

Allwright intervenes

Allwright intervened, asking Kaur why she felt it was fair to have pensioners save for retirement only to have their pension reduced or taken away to help younger people. Kaur responded by questioning whether welfare should go to people who have money and paid-off mortgages while the younger generation has nothing.

She said she is sick and tired of not looking after the younger generation, citing Alan Milburn's report about a lost generation, and criticised the reaction to any mention of pensions as an attack.

Following the clash, viewers responded on X. One replied questioning whether Kaur would hand over her pension when she gets it. Another noted that many of the older generation were also young and had nothing once, often starting work at 15 and contributing until retirement. A third tweeted that people are in mortgage-free homes because they have paid for them over the last 25 years.