I'm A Celebrity's fake AJ Odudu elimination is a cop-out
I'm A Celeb fake AJ Odudu elimination is a cop-out

In the least surprising twist imaginable, after evicting her on the first episode, I'm A Celebrity... Get Me Out of Here! has confirmed that contestant AJ Odudu hasn't been ousted after all. It was entirely anticlimactic.

Writing as a humongous AJ fan, this was a wasted opportunity to do something genuinely thrilling on I'm A Celeb after 25 years. As the set up, on Monday's launch show, Ant and Dec announced that for the first time, one camp mate would be booted from the jungle before they even got a chance to see their hammock, eat a dish of rice and beans, or shower in an ice cold waterfall. Then, after two challenges, AJ and actress Claire Sweeney were left to battle it out to avoid being the unfortunate star to win the accolade of the shortest stint on I'm A Celebrity ever.

AJ's Fake Eviction Unravels

That honour fell eventually to AJ, after losing to a round of questions while wearing a dome full of crickets on their heads – though the reported £150,000 fee would have softened the blow for less than a day's work. But it was glaringly obvious to everyone watching that she was going nowhere.

AJ didn't appear on I'm A Celeb's spin-off series Unpacked after her eviction, and it was unlikely ITV would have flown her to Australia for an eye-watering sum of money and not made the most of the presenter. Her social media profiles were still clearly being managed by someone else, and the biggest clue to me that the present would be staying put: I'm A Celebrity just isn't brave enough to deliver such a colossal blow.

At the end of last night's episode, AJ received a call telling her 'all is not as it seems'. Actually, everything was as it seems for those of us who saw it coming, because she appears to be heading to a secret location where more will be revealed in due course. Presumably she'll be joined by this year's late arrival, who has already been revealed as Celebrity Juice comic Leigh Francis.

A Missed Opportunity for Real Stakes

I'm aware I sound like a broken record constantly harking back to The Traitors, but part of the success of that show is that it displays absolutely no mercy, even to its most popular characters and most high profile celebrities. The format of the show and not pulling punches come above the longevity of its cast.

Of course, the BBC hasn't blown quite the same budget getting Hollywood royalty like Richard E. Grant to Inverness, but I would have loved to see I'm A Celebrity take a really massive swing and genuinely play a more brutal game with this cast than it ever has before. And they need all the advice they can get – Monday's episode delivered its lowest overnight audience for a launch show to date, at just 4.8 million viewers. In comparison last year drew in 6.6 million average viewers.

Still, it was ITV's most-watched show outside of football this year and streaming figures will add well over a million more viewers to those disappointing numbers. This year's line-up is packed with star power, and arguably the show's biggest yet – which technically should help get more numbers in. Wayne Rooney is an unbelievably huge draw, eclipsing the hysteria his wife triggered when she signed up three years ago.

The Case for a Real Shock Elimination

And there are several other massive names joining him: Gavin & Stacey's Joanna Page; Kaiser Chiefs frontman and former The Voice coach Ricky Wilson; queen of the huns Claire Sweeney; and AJ is by far one of the most sought-after and popular television presenters of the moment. If this isn't an audience-grabbing line-up, then the problem lies with the format.

Personally, I've actually found the last three or four series of I'm A Celebrity much stronger than it's been for years; genuinely impressive line-ups which boast both big names and a real sense of humour, which is where, for me, reality television shines the most. But if there is one lesson to be learned from the success of The Traitors, it's that viewers love to be emotionally tortured with big twists that throw even their favourite contestants into jeopardy or out of the game entirely.

AJ would have been the perfect sacrificial lamb for I'm A Celebrity. She's riding high off the biggest series of Big Brother ITV has ever seen – exceeding 200million views – she's one of the most exciting names on the list, and she's both one of the most genuine stars we have and hugely entertaining. She will go far on I'm A Celebrity – but that is exactly why I actually think it's a shame that her elimination wasn't real – and that we all saw it coming.

While I am relieved we haven't lost a strong contender to be the first person of colour to ever win I'm A Celebrity UK in its 25 years, I am gutted they weren't bold enough to actually raise the stakes by trying something genuinely game-changing as a real shock elimination. Earlier this year, ITV aired its second series of I'm A Celebrity: South Africa. Camp mates there aren't voted off by the public; instead, they're eliminated through challenges. As a result, the most popular camp mates can be sent packing first, adding an extra level of jeopardy throughout the series.

Personally, I'm glad there's a public vote in I'm A Celebrity, and stars are both punished and rewarded for their behaviour in camp – rather than their strengths and weaknesses in the challenges. But it would have been so refreshing to see I'm A Celebrity bring out a big gun at least this one time and prove it really is taking no prisoners: any camp mate could go at any time and we should all be petrified for our favourites. The saving grace is we'll see more AJ, which is never a bad thing. But the stakes of reality television have evolved, and I'm A Celebrity should have evolved with it.