Prince Harry and Meghan Markle would have faced reputational ruin if the Royal Family had abandoned its long-standing tradition of never responding to criticism, according to broadcaster Carole Malone.
Speaking on the Royals Unscripted podcast, Malone said the Firm's motto of "never complain, never explain" has protected the Duke and Duchess of Sussex from the consequences of a full-scale royal rebuttal.
Tradition Shields Sussexes
Ms Malone told host James Walker: "They're so lucky the royals have this rule, 'never complain, never explain'. Because if the royals had gone firing on all cylinders, those two would have been destroyed."
The principle, which she traced to Walter Bagehot's 1867 work The English Constitution and its argument that the monarchy's power is tied to its mystery, has stopped senior royals from answering Harry and Meghan's public criticism, including allegations of mistreatment and claims of attempts to undermine the monarchy.
"What the royals have had to endure is this week after week, month after month attack on them without responding," she added. "If I was being attacked in that way, I would implode if I couldn't respond ... which is why I think William is so entrenched, so determined not to have [Harry] back in."
Return to the UK
The duke and duchess moved back to the UK in August, six years after their acrimonious split with the Firm and move to California. In the years between, they voiced their frustrations with the Palace on several platforms, including Harry's memoir Spare, an Oprah interview and a Netflix documentary.
Their return raised speculation of closer ties to King Charles and the monarchy, but tensions surfaced within weeks over whether they should be regarded as "private citizens" or "public figures". They have also faced criticism over an apparent "half in, half out" arrangement, mixing quasi-royal duties with commercial ventures in a way that was expressly forbidden by the late Queen Elizabeth II and opposed by the King.
Call for Reconciliation
Despite the friction, Harry told Q last month that he wants his disagreements with Charles and Prince William to "work out".
"With everything else that's going on in the world, the most important thing is to reconcile - that's the key point," he said. Asked whether he could repair the "wound" between the Sussexes and the Palace, he replied: "Yeah, of course. I think every wound... look, scars stick around forever but... what your perception is and what your mindset is to these things that have happened, certainly letting go of the past, that's something that I would encourage everybody to do."