Coronation Street fans are convinced they have uncovered the truth behind Sarah Platt and Gary Windass's secretive behavior on the ITV soap, and they believe it is far more sinister than an affair.
Fans Speculate on Hidden Motives
Viewers have been buzzing with theories after recent episodes showed the characters acting increasingly suspicious. Their behavior has included hushed phone calls, private meetings, and visible panic, leading many to suspect they are involved in something serious.
After episodes where they appeared distressed over updates in the Theo Silverton murder case, fans began to speculate about their involvement. Sarah was seen comforting Gary, who seemed deeply troubled, further fueling rumors.
Popular Theories Emerge
Taking to social media, fans shared several theories. One popular idea is that either Sarah or Gary killed Theo, with the other helping to cover it up. Another theory suggests Gary may be ill and has confided only in Sarah, keeping it from his partner Maria Connor.
A detailed post outlined three possibilities: first, that Sarah found Todd's mobile near Theo's body and gave it to Gary for disposal to protect Todd. Second, that Gary is ill and only Sarah knows. Third, that Gary confronted Theo, a fight ensued, and Gary struck him, believing he was dead.
Many fans dismissed the idea of an affair, noting that their behavior seems too anxious for a romantic secret. One fan remarked, "I'm not buying that Sarah and Gary are having an affair; they’re acting way too suspicious about something else."
Another viewer pointed out, "Something weird is happening between Sarah and Gary, and I’m not sure it’s that they’re having an affair." Others questioned if Gary was the killer, with one fan asking, "Are we all in agreement that it was probably Gary that killed Theo?"
A fan added, "It's nothing to do with an affair obviously. As Gary is really scared and he wouldn't be over an affair obviously! And he mentioned Summer. So I think Sarah killed Theo or he did and she knows or they both pushed him!"
Coronation Street airs weeknights at 8:30pm on ITV1 and ITV X. Follow Mirror Celebs and TV on TikTok, Snapchat, Instagram, Twitter, Facebook, YouTube, and Threads.
