Cardiff schools face £750 parking charge under council levy plans
Cardiff schools face £750 parking charge under levy plans

School leaders in Cardiff have warned that a council proposal to charge for parking spaces on school land would divert money away from classrooms and teaching. Cardiff council is consulting on plans to introduce a workplace levy that would charge employers £750 per year for each parking place provided.

The council says the charge could raise £10m a year, but concerns have been raised by groups including motoring organisations. The council has said no final decision has been made and that the levy is an alternative to another suggestion of road charges.

Levy details and rationale

The £750 figure was chosen, according to the council, because it is similar to the cost of an annual bus pass and less expensive than private car parking, as annual season parking charges in Cardiff car parks average approximately £1,500 per year.

A workplace levy has been in place in Nottingham since 2012. In Nottingham, the charge only applies to employers who provide 11 or more parking spaces. Smaller employers are 100% discounted, as are spaces for disabled people, NHS premises and emergency services. In the year of its introduction the cost was £288 a year and it is now £562.

School leaders' response

WalesOnline understands headteachers were told about the consultation at a meeting in October, and school leaders union NAHT has sent a written response as part of the consultation. In it the union says the levy would "divert critical funds directly away from classroom provision, teaching resources, and pupil support".

The letter sent to the council reads: "NAHT Cymru strongly objects to the inclusion of schools and educational settings within the workplace parking levy (WPL), or to any mechanism that results in a financial penalty being passed on to school staff or drawn from already strained school budgets.

"School leaders, teachers, and support staff perform an essential public service. Unlike many office-based workers, school staff cannot work remotely and frequently carry heavy teaching materials, specialist equipment, or work unsociable hours before and after school.

"If school governance structures or local authorities are liable for paying the annual levy per parking bay, this would divert critical funds directly away from classroom provision, teaching resources, and pupil support.

"School budgets in Cardiff are under unprecedented pressure and no transport levy should penalise school operational funding.

"If employers (or schools) elect to pass the licensing charge directly to staff to park at their place of work, this acts as an unpalatable 'tax on working'.

"In the context of ongoing cost-of-living pressures and real-terms pay erosion, introducing a cost for staff to park at school is unacceptable.

"Public transport networks, particularly for staff commuting from outlying rural areas, the south Wales valleys, or early/late shifts (e.g., breakfast club supervision, extracurricular activities, and parents' evenings), are rarely frequent or direct enough to replace car travel.

"Cardiff schools compete with neighbouring local authorities for high-quality educators and support staff. Imposing parking charges on school staff in Cardiff creates a clear competitive disadvantage, exacerbating existing recruitment and retention challenges."

The union argues there should be a 100% statutory exemption for all primary, secondary, special schools, and pupil referral units, and protection so costs are not passed on to staff. It also calls for "targeted investment" in school transport routes so any money from commercial or non-educational sectors must be directly channelled into safer active travel routes around schools.

"While NAHT Cymru supports environmental initiatives and investments in green transport, schools must not be treated as commercial enterprises," the union's submission reads. "Penalising dedicated public sector workers and risking education budgets is not an equitable way to fund transport infrastructure."

Wider concern and next steps

Claire Armitstead, director of the Association of School and College Leaders (ASCL) Cymru, said: "We're aware of proposals to introduce a workplace parking levy in Cardiff.

"This is currently being consulted on and it appears that no decision has been made regarding application of the levy on public sector workers. It's entirely impractical for this levy to be applied to schools and doing so would be incredibly damaging.

"We can't believe the purpose of this scheme is to leave schools worse off financially and therefore a specific exemption will need to be put in place."

The consultation runs until January 17.