Over two years ago, on a brisk afternoon in February, Tom Usher found out that one of his best mates had been sexually assaulting women for many years. He had just been eating dinner with him when, unbeknown to them, they said their last goodbye. As he turned to walk away, Usher's phone rang. A mutual friend called to tell him he had sexually assaulted her, and many other women.
The Phenomenology of a Power Imbalance
In the wake of many famous men being outed as predators, rapists, and abusers of power, the question always seems to be: "How did they get away with it?" Of course, there is no way money doesn't feature. David Walliams made HarperCollins hundreds of millions in book sales. Russell Brand was probably making his network a tidy sum as well. Harvey Weinstein, Jeffrey Epstein, Jimmy Savile, all the same. The people around them, with their good careers, comfortable lives and loving families, depended on the money they made, while ignoring the calculated evil they did.
Power too: institutional, legal, psychological. The ability to ruin lives, the ability to get injunctions, the ability to ask for favours and blind eyes from other powerful people. People always ask, either in bad faith or idiocy, why don't these women speak up at the time, why don't these women go straight to the police? When there's every indication that their lives will be made a living hell for doing so, even if they do get the glimmer of justice. That's the phenomenology of a power imbalance. It creates fear, uncertainty, inaction.
Male Loyalty and Its Consequences
From Usher's personal experience, a lot of it is that men are often too scared or insecure to speak up, to challenge and to question their friends, or other men, for fear of breaking this male loyalty, for ruining a friendship, or for simply feeling uncomfortable and not fitting in.
After everyone found out, Usher saw their shared friends stick by him. They called him on his behalf trying to find out what he knew, they still went on holiday with him, their families still spent time together. And it made him think: as a man is this something he should be doing too? Is blind loyalty just what it means to have male friendship? He was there for him when he was down, he had his back no matter what and he just cut him off straight away, and never spoke to him again.
Usher fell into a deep depression about it all and his social life withered away. This was someone he trusted and loved, who in his eyes was a good man, yet was doing horrible things to women he cared about, his friends, while he was completely unaware, often at the same parties. The thoughts consumed him: why didn't he notice, were there signs he should have seen, was he in some way guilty too?
Reassessing Values and Accountability
Now, Usher doesn't think of himself as a good man. He's always reassessing his values and he is constantly questioning his own behaviour. He's lied, cheated and hurt women — it's not comfortable to acknowledge it out loud but it's better than living a lie that you're inherently good, no matter what. He is not devoid of the masculinity that benefits him every day in a male-dominated society, he is not beyond scrutiny for his own cowardice or ill-treatment of women. But there were huge social and psychological consequences for him after he cut his friend off and they weren't pleasant, and that should be acknowledged.
Good people aren't always good, bad people aren't always bad. In his lifetime, Usher has noticed the internet has made us increasingly more susceptible to black or white thinking. This person has done one bad thing, they must forever be a bad person, that person has done a few good things, they must obviously be a good person. This binary thinking makes it easier for us all, with our over-stimulated brains, to make comfortable snap judgments. When the truth is, the only really bad people he knows are the ones who do bad things and don't feel accountable for them.
A Courtroom Reunion and a Call to Action
Roughly two years after that February afternoon, Usher's past friend was convicted of sexual assault. He was in court that day and he arrived late and sweating, bursting into the world's quietest room while he was giving evidence. They locked eyes for what felt like much too long, and he thought he would recognise the man looking back at him, but his face had changed. The features were the same but the love that imbues the eyes of your friends had disappeared, and he's never seen him again.
Usher was there supporting the woman who was brave enough to take a stand. She too, like Brand's victims, had her own personal details combed over in lurid detail, her own integrity questioned, by a scathing defence lawyer. She too relied solely on witness testimony, something his defence lawyer mocked in his closing remarks. Yet she still won, despite the odds against her.
There aren't any more words men can write that make that trauma better. But there are actions men can take, every day, and they're unfortunately quite uncomfortable: challenging each other, speaking up, not letting things slide, not continuing to be the social scaffolding abusive men stand on. It has to come from men, because the simple fact is that men usually only listen to other men. The everyday consequences and accountability, which are up to all of us to enforce, are the social disruption that can really provide meaningful change.