Mother accused of Munchausen's by proxy over toddler's surgery
Mother accused of Munchausen's by proxy over surgery

A West Virginia mother has been accused of Munchausen Syndrome by proxy after an investigation found her two-year-old child was taken to the doctor 175 times and underwent surgery that detectives say was not medically necessary.

Emilee Guzman, 29, was arrested by the Monongalia County Sheriff's Office (MCSO) on claims of medical abuse and child neglect involving the unnamed two-year-old and a nine-year-old child. Her husband, Milton Alexander Guzman Cisneros, and a woman named Caitlin Jean Meredith, who lives with the couple in Morgantown, West Virginia, were also arrested. The latter two face charges of child neglect creating risk of bodily injury, according to local authorities.

Investigation into reported medical history

The sheriff's office said in a press release that they were alerted to 'a child's reported medical history and the overall welfare of two children', which led to the repeated doctor's visits coming to light. Emilee reportedly told medical staff that the child had Avoidant/Restrictive Food Intake Disorder (ARFID), a condition in which youngsters fear and refuse certain foods, as well as microgastria, a rare birth defect causing an abnormally small stomach.

As a result, the toddler had surgery to have a gastronomic tube fitted. Detectives have said the procedure was not medically necessary. According to WOWT, the surgeon who performed the operation said he would not have carried it out if he had been given more information into the case, adding that the tube could prove very painful for a child and could cause serious harm.

Conditions at the family home

After the child was placed in foster care away from Guzman, they were eating a variety of food normally but did not want anyone near the tube to clean it and clearly found it uncomfortable. Authorities who searched Emilee's home also cited 'hazardous and unsanitary living conditions and troubling treatment of the children within the household', including cockroaches, an infestation of gnats and flies, and dried faeces thought to be from cats and possibly from humans, People reports.

Officials also examined communications between Emilee and Caitlin Meredith that suggested the nine-year-old child had been subjected to 'troubling treatment' including threats and descriptions of physical punishment.

Understanding Munchausen's by proxy

Munchausen Syndrome is a psychological disorder in which a person pretends to be ill or fakes symptoms of an illness to gain attention. The main intention is to spark concern in others and get sympathy, rather than for practical benefit such as claiming incapacity allowance. Munchausen's by proxy is a form of the condition in which the sufferer claims somebody else, such as their child, is ill.

The condition gets its name from a German aristocrat, Baron von Munchausen, known for telling far-fetched tales about his behaviour. The cause can be complex and many patients refuse psychiatric treatment, but it has been suggested it may be caused by childhood trauma, such as parental neglect and abandonment. Some evidence also suggests that people who had extensive medical procedures or prolonged medical attention in childhood may develop the condition later, as they associate childhood memories with a sense of being cared for.