A woman allegedly sexually abused by three men in one night after being drugged said she felt 'woozy' the next morning, a trial heard. Nine men are on trial accused of sexual offences against the woman.
The husband, a man in his 60s from Stockport, has admitted multiple offences, including rape and administering substances with intent to stupefy his wife so other men could engage in sexual activity with her. The Manchester Evening News and other media organisations are not naming the man in order to protect his victim's anonymity. The nine men on trial deny the charges they face.
Contact offenders and non-contact offenders
Seven of the nine defendants have been described as 'contact offenders', who jurors heard visited the couple's home expecting her to be 'wasted' and 'out of it'. It is alleged the 'contact offenders' are taxi driver Philip Wild, 59; recruitment agency worker Mohammed Sabir, 28; building supplies employee Jordan Wallace, 31; industrial cleaning firm worker Alan Keelan, 42; retiree Robert Stewart, 70; sheet metal worker Richard Townsend, 38; and senior paramedic Jonathan Kirk, 43.
The Crown alleges 'non-contact' offenders, who allegedly 'hid behind a screen' as they conspired to administer substances to the wife, are kitchen firm sales rep David Graves, 60; and self-employed mechanic Daniel Rayner, 42. Four other men - Keith Fotheringham, Karl Lindsay, Sean Peers and Graham Brougham - pleaded guilty at earlier hearings to various offences linked to the case.
Messages after the alleged abuse
Jurors heard that after being asked what he had given her 'drug wise' on the night of September 21 last year, the husband told Fotheringham '20mg'. Mr Sabir and Mr Stewart are both accused of raping her after attending the house in the early hours. The husband also sexually abused his wife, the court heard. Prosecutor Louise Oakley KC said the wife had allegedly been abused that night for three hours and 47 minutes.
The KC said the husband and wife had been out the night before with friends. Jurors heard a friend of the wife texted her just before 9am on September 21 that day to say: "Thanks for a great night - loved the food, the game and best of all the company." The wife, it was said, replied at about 1.30pm that day: "I've only just woken up. What all that about."
Her friend replied: "Omg we woke up at 8.30 which is late for me. Feeling a bit hungover. What a great night couldn't believe what time we left." The wife asked: "What time did you leave?" The friend said: "Our ring door camera was at 2.05." The wife said: "8.30 is late for me usually. [The husband] is up and doing stuff. It was a good night."
The wife replied: "I fell back to sleep again. Feel all wobbly." The friend said: "Gosh you must have needed it. You have had a very busy week though." At about 3.30pm the wife said: "I've not been up long. Didn't wake up until after 1pm. Had a brew and fell back to sleep. Still feel woozy. What's wrong with me?"
The wife told another friend: "Do you feel ok. I still feel a bit weird. It was a good night though. Did you both enjoy." The friend said: "I didn't feel sick this morning better now but I know I've been drinking." The wife said: "I'm still in my PJs feeling wobbly but not hungover. Just weird." She added: "Not eaten yet. Cooking a Sunday roast which I'm looking forward to. Might have to hare of the dog whilst I'm watching Strictly."
Alleged messages about the abuse
At about 3pm on September 21, Fotheringham asked the husband: "Did you enjoy her being f*****." The husband said: "Yes, very nervous though." Fotheringham, the court heard, said: "Why. What did you give her last night drug wise." The husband said: "20mg." Fotheringham said: "She was gone should have done more she have no recollection of being f*****." The husband replied: "None but she thinks she's not well or something."
As the prosecution case continued in the trial, the jury continued to be told of the sequence of events. Jurors heard that on August 24 last year, Karl Lindsay messaged the husband to say: "I need to see more." The husband then sent images to Lindsay of Jonathan Kirk's attendance at the home, it was said. Lindsay added to the husband: "If I'm to keep supplying. I need to see her f***** and sp***** on."
In the early hours of August 25, the husband, the court heard, messaged Mr Sabir to say: "You still interested in coming round next time she is wasted." The husband then sent an image of his wife lying on her back in bed with her genitals exposed to Mr Sabir, jurors were told. A red love heart emoji was placed over her face, prosecutor Louise Oakley KC said. "Yes 100 per cent." Mr Sabir replied, the court heard.
Jurors were told a message thread between Mr Kirk and the husband. It began with the husband appearing to arrange to meet Mr Kirk, the court heard. Mr Kirk, it was said, messaged: "I was drunk last night and wished I was inside your wife." The husband replied: "You will be again sooner or later. Next time we'll plan it better." Mr Kirk, it was said, added: "Mmm." Later the husband told Mr Kirk: "Some time free tomorrow, missus might be drinking Saturday night." Mr Kirk, the court heard, replied: "Working."
On August 31, Lindsay messaged the husband to say: "U ok - I sent you medicine." Daniel Rayner, the court heard, asked the husband: "Hey matey how's it going have u had any more fun with your wife this weekend?"
In a message to Contact BL, the husband said: "Yes I'd love to see her f****** other guys, unfortunately she definitely wouldn't. She is unaware I'm here. Most of the pics are sneaked or when she is very drunk, totally wasted like this." In a message to the husband, Contact BQ said: "Let me know if you want me to come. If not not a problem just want to know whether or not to get ready for bed haha." The husband replied: "If you're totally happy raping my drunk wife as I film it."
Jurors heard that on September 2 last year, Fotheringham messaged the husband to say: "How many pills you got left and when was last time you did anything with her." The husband replied: "I still have them all. Why are you asking." Fotheringham said: "I thought we had a pact and trust." The husband said: "Why don't you just say or ask what you're thinking instead of going around the houses. What's this pact you think we have. I still have all you sent, what is this pact?"
"So we have nothing is that what your saying," Fotheringham replied. "Don't understand what you're asking," the husband said. Fotheringham said: "I saw the footage of the different guys in the house. She looked well drugged to me. I thought I would get to see everything you were doing with or without me. That's why I sent you tabs."
The husband said: "I still have the tabs, when I use them I will tell you. Do you want them back?" Fotheringham said: "Why don't you show me the stuff with the guys, never showed me yet put them up [online] for all those to see." The husband said: "You are not always available, she is my wife, you are sounding a bit obsessive that's a bit worrying." The following day, the husband asked Fotheringham: "Do we need to voice chat you seemed a little annoyed last night." Fotheringham replied: "No totally fine. As you said, she's your wife."
On September 9, Fotheringham asked the husband: "Is there anything new to show me. I would really like to see these other guys with her. Do I get to see her being used by others." The husband replied: "Will send what I have but really busy." The husband then sent images to Fotheringham of his wife and of Mr Wild's attendance, jurors heard.
Fotheringham asked the husband: "Why did they not use her properly. I can see she wasn't completely drugged missed opportunity you need her totally out. I want to see her f***** and enjoyed." The husband said: "So do I but it’s not easy and it’s the next day effects on her are a big problem." Fotheringham said: "Ask on site if there are anything that gives less effects." The husband replied: "I've already done that, GHB but that is very difficult for me to get hold of and expensive."
Jurors heard that on September 11, the husband searched online: "Dangers of mixing xanax and alcohol." On September 15, Fotheringham asked the husband: "When are you using her again." The husband replied: "I'm not sure, gotta be careful not to over do it, waiting for her to be properly wasted not just very drunk after last time." Later Fotheringham told the husband: "This is only my feeling but if I knew my wife was heavy sleeper like [the wife] I'd be planning meticulously how to drug and use but that's just me."
The husband said: "Yes but not as comfortable with them as you, one still lived 40 miles away, another was too rough, and chatted to several who just want a quick in and out never to be seen again." Fotheringham asked the husband: "Does any of mates know you do this does any of them drug their wife." The husband told Fotheringham: "No hidden cam too risky telling anyone who knows her." The husband later said: "Been looking for someone local that I feel like I can trust." After sending Fotheringham a video of Mr Wallace's attendance at the house, the husband told him: "He was too rough and too eager I had to throw him out in the end."
Jurors heard that on September 16, Lindsay messaged the husband to ask: "Any more joy yet." "Not yet," the husband replied. "Gotta be sure she doesn't get suspicious." The court that day Mr Sabir messaged the husband to ask: "Free tonight?" "Maybe Saturday night," the husband replied. Jurors heard that on September 17, Fotheringham told the husband: "Must use [the wife] this weekend plan it me and you." "Must!", the husband replied. "It depends on what we're doing on Saturday night and what time I get back from the game."
The court heard that on September 19, David Graves told the husband: "You missed a chance last night." Jurors heard that in the early hours, the husband had made a number of calls to Mr Graves. The husband replied: "I know what I'm doing. You were a pain last night. You need patience. You should also give some feedback text. And why is your cam off?" Mr Graves, jurors heard, said: "Feedback she was wrecked."
The jury heard of a chat between the husband and Contact G on September 20. Contact G told the husband: "If you can give me some dates/evenings that work for you/ [the wife] then I'll head up with the goodies." In the early hours of September 21, Fotheringham asked the husband: "You had a good night." The husband said: "We're at home she's pi**** but still got friends here, not had any tabs yet. Still drinking."
Fotheringham said: "Ok just let me know. Looking good. Pity you couldn't drug everyone." Jurors were shown a video taken by the husband, said to show the wife getting ready for bed. Fotheringham messaged the husband: "Get her naked. Let's go you give her anything. She pi**** too good an opportunity." "Have tabs crushed in pipette trying to get in her," the husband said. Later Fotheringham said: "Get someone in to f*** her." "No way she's just been talking," the husband said.
Later the husband told Fotheringham: "Have Asian guy nearby wants her, can he?" Fotheringham replied: "Yes. But film everything. Is she out?" Fotheringham continued: "I want her used." The husband said: "He on his way." Jurors then heard messages between the husband and Mohammed Sabir. The husband told him: "She's almost knocked out. Where are you." Mr Sabir was provided with the address, jurors heard. The husband told him: "Can't promise what's on offer, see how she is when you get here."
Mr Sabir then attended the house for a second time in the early hours of September 21, the court was told. The first video taken by the husband of Mr Sabir in the bedroom was just after 3.30am, the court heard. Mr Sabir also took images on his phone, the court heard. Mr Sabir is accused of committing two counts of rape during his visit, which he denies.
Jurors heard Fotheringham messaged the husband during Mr Sabir's visit on September 21 to ask: "Is she being f*****. Used." Mr Sabir then sent the husband videos he took during his attendance at the house, it was said. Fotheringham then asked: "Anything mate." The husband sent him an image which showed Mr Sabir during his attendance. Fotheringham added to the husband: "Do more that's it, waste she's out." He added: "Tell me you have so much more. Did she get f***** show me."
Jurors heard Robert Stewart also attended the house on September 21. "Fancy doing my wife," the husband asked. "Oh yes," Mr Stewart was said to have replied. "Come round now," the husband said, before giving him the postcode for his home. Mr Stewart was said to have booked a taxi to take him to the house. The husband filmed himself sexually abusing his wife, jurors heard. Mr Stewart arrived at the house at 5.22am, jurors heard. He is accused of two counts of rape said to have occurred at the house, which he denies.
The husband took images of the alleged abuse. On one of the images a 'red love heart emoji' was placed on the wife's face, the court heard. In one of the clips, the husband can be heard to ask Mr Stewart: "Do you want to kiss her?" Mr Stewart then kissed the woman, jurors were told. The husband can be heard to ask Mr Stewart: "Do you like that then?" Ms Oakley told jurors the husband continued to abuse the wife in the early hours after Mr Stewart's attendance, filming himself doing so.
Just after 6am Mr Stewart called for a taxi from a barber's shop, the court heard. The husband then sent images of his wife and Mr Stewart to Fotheringham and Lindsay, it was said. Jurors heard Fotheringham told the husband: "Superb hope there is more c*** in mouth." Lindsay told the husband: "More plz."
The court was told that at about 10.30pm on September 21, Robert Stewart messaged the husband to say: "Mate have had a bad feeling about it all day. Delete all images from your phone etc as its too risky. Remember what happened to the guy in France. Delete me from your phone and life. If she caught you out it would be a whole lot of trouble and end of your marriage and ruin your life."
Mr Stewart, it was said, told the husband: "Also recommend resetting your phone back to factory settings. Gets rid of everything." He asked the husband: "Have you disposed of everything and reset your phone to factory settings?" The husband replied: "You've nothing to worry about, have you deleted everything?" Mr Stewart said: "Yes I have, be careful what you put on here, moderators active." The following morning, on September 22, the husband told Mr Stewart: "Yes completely understand, could be bad for both of us."
Defendants and charges
David Graves, 59, of Milton Avenue, Derbyshire, denies one count of conspiracy to rape; one count of conspiracy to commit assault by penetration; and one count of conspiracy to administer a substance with intent. Robert Stewart, 70, of Sandpiper Drive, Stockport, denies one count of conspiracy to rape; one count of conspiracy to administer a substance with intent and two counts of rape.
Philip Wild, 58, of St Davids Road, Cheadle, denies one count of conspiracy to rape; one count of sexual assault; one count of attempted rape; and one count of assault by penetration. Daniel Rayner, 42, of Sherwood Drive, Whitstable, denies one count of conspiracy to rape; one count of conspiracy to commit assault by penetration; and one count of conspiracy to administer a substance with intent.
Mohammed Sabir, 28, of no fixed address, denies one count of conspiracy to rape and three counts of rape. Jordan Wallace, 31, of Hindsford Close, Wythenshawe, denies one count of rape and one count of attempted rape. Alan Keelan, 42, of Foscarn Drive, Wythenshawe, denies two counts of attempted rape and one count of assault by penetration. Richard Townsend, 37, of Woodland Street, Heywood, denies one count of assault by penetration. Jonathan Kirk, 43, of Telford Close, Macclesfield, denies one count of conspiracy to rape and two counts of rape.
Four other men pleaded guilty at earlier hearings to various offences linked to the case, the jury has been told. They are Keith Fotheringham, 59, of Cleghorn Street, Dundee; Karl Lindsay, 56, of Wordsworth Drive, Taunton; Sean Peers, 38, formerly of Sandwich Road in Eccles, now of Stockport; and Graham Brougham, 74, of Birtwistle Road, Northwich, Cheshire. The trial is being held at Minshull Street Crown Court in Manchester.