Woman loses chicken road case, ordered to pay £8,700 costs
Woman loses chicken road case, ordered to pay costs

A woman who sued her private-hire driver after he braked sharply to avoid hitting a chicken has lost her court case and been ordered to pay £8,700 in legal costs.

The judge ruled that although she was an 'innocent passenger', the driver was not at fault for the incident. Instead, the chicken caused the drama after wandering into the road.

Incident on Holland Road

Ms Yvonne Chen Qianyun was travelling in a private-hire car driven by Mr Tan Teng Kiat along Holland Road in Singapore on February 19, 2024, according to CNA.

A chicken crossed in front of the vehicle ahead, forcing its driver to brake. Mr Tan then applied his own brakes to avoid crashing into it. He said he had been travelling at around 50km/h and was about 10 metres behind the car in front.

Claim dismissed

Ms Chen, whose injuries were not specified in the judgment, sued him for negligence. She argued that he had failed to leave enough room between the vehicles, forcing him to make an 'abrupt and forceful stop'. She also claimed his braking was more forceful than reasonably necessary.

Mr Tan denied the allegations, saying he had enough distance and time to stop safely. He also claimed Ms Chen initially asked him whether he had noted the number plate of the car in front, as she wanted to pursue its driver over her worsening back pain. According to Mr Tan, she even asked him to act as a witness in that potential claim, before later changing her mind about who to sue.

Other pending cases

Judge Ng also noted that Ms Chen had at least two other cases pending before the district court, both relating to separate road accidents. One involved a private-hire car in which she was a passenger in September 2022. The other concerned an accident in October 2024 involving her husband's car, in which she was also a passenger.

Ms Chen's claim was dismissed, and she was ordered to pay S$15,000 in costs. The judge said: 'The law does not seek out a tortfeasor for every loss that is suffered. In an imperfect world, some losses must lie where they fall.'

'This incident, caused as it was by a chicken crossing the road, was unfortunately, but also undoubtedly, part of the vicissitudes of life.'