Two holiday lets in the Pembrokeshire village of Lamphey have been found to have operated without planning permission for 10 years, despite welcoming hundreds of tourists and receiving strong online reviews.
The properties, run by Hilary Sharp of Lamphey Park Limited, were advertised through websites including Airbnb, Expedia and Booking.com since 2016. The local authority only recently discovered the lets had been operating without the necessary permission.
Popular with tourists despite lack of permission
The holiday lets at Lamphey Studios attracted many visitors who left positive feedback, unaware the accommodation should not have been in use. The site holds a 6.8 overall rating on Booking.com, with an 8.4 rating, and 35 of 99 reviewers rated it "superb". Guests particularly praised the peacefulness, location and scenery.
After Pembrokeshire County Council contacted the owner, Sharp, through agent Etienne Sharp, sought a certificate of lawfulness to allow the holiday lets to remain retrospectively. Such a certificate permits a development to stay if the applicant can prove continuous use over a prolonged period without enforcement action.
Retrospective application and evidence
The applicants stated the units had operated as self-catered, self-contained holiday lets for a decade, as part of a larger holiday complex and bed and breakfast business on the site. They also expressed hope to convert the two units into one dwelling while continuing holiday use.
An officer report noted the application site forms part of a wider complex operated as holiday accommodation and a bed and breakfast business. Regarding the conversion intentions, it said these relate to possible future development and do not form part of the application, with the assessment confined solely to whether the existing use as two self-contained short-term holiday accommodation units is lawful through the passage of time.
Permission history and lawfulness ruling
Planning permission was granted in 2009 for converting an outbuilding to a workshop and studio, with a no full occupation condition. However, it was not known whether the building was ever used for that purpose.
Evidence supporting the lawfulness application included a detailed booking schedule recording reservation dates, arrival and departure dates, number of nights, prices and booking sources for the two units, identified as 'S' or 'Studio' and 'Cwtch'. A Booking.com listing for Lamphey Studios, showing the building, accommodation and guest reviews, along with HMRC returns for Lower Lamphey Park Limited, was also submitted.
Of the bookings made through sources including Booking.com, Expedia and direct or offline bookings, the report said the nature, frequency and duration of recorded stays are consistent with commercial short-term holiday accommodation use. It concluded the units had operated continuously for more than four years before the application date, making them immune from enforcement action and lawful.