PensionBee has called on the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) to ban flat fees on pension pots worth less than £5,000, warning that some of the smallest workplace pots could lose up to 16 per cent of their value to charges in a single year, before investment performance is even considered.
The pension provider has submitted recommendations in response to the DWP's Small Pots: a pathway for consolidation consultation, which sets out plans to address the growing number of small, inactive workplace pensions. PensionBee is urging the UK Government to introduce stronger protections for people with smaller pension savings and to reconsider proposals that could see millions of pots automatically transferred between providers without their owners' consent.
Charges could reduce retirement savings
PensionBee analysed published charging structures at some of the UK's largest master trust pension schemes and found that flat fees, combined with percentage charges, could take a substantial proportion of smaller pots. Its analysis found that annual charges could account for 16 per cent of a £150 pension pot, 9.9 per cent of a £250 pot, 5.1 per cent of a £500 pot, 2.8 per cent of a £1,000 pot, and 0.9 per cent of a £5,000 pot.
These amounts represent the highest charges identified for different pot sizes across the schemes examined, rather than charges applied universally by pension providers. PensionBee also modelled the impact on a £500 pension pot left untouched for ten years. Despite assuming annual investment growth of five per cent, the company found that charges at one provider could leave the pot worth slightly less than its original value after a decade. Without a flat fee, the same £500 pot could grow to around £790 over the period.
Under existing rules, flat fees can be applied to defined contribution workplace pension pots worth more than £100 in qualifying default arrangements. PensionBee wants protection extended by banning flat fees on pension pots worth less than £5,000 in the relevant schemes.
Concerns over automatic pension transfers
The company has also raised concerns about plans to automatically consolidate smaller workplace pensions. The proposed system is intended to reduce the number of forgotten or inactive pension pots created when employees move between jobs. However, PensionBee argues that automatic transfers could result in people's retirement savings being moved to unfamiliar providers without their explicit consent.
It is calling for the proposed arrangements to operate on an opt-in basis, allowing savers to decide whether their money should be transferred and which provider should receive it. PensionBee also wants the UK Government to prioritise the introduction of the MoneyHelper Pensions Dashboard, which is intended to allow people to view their pension savings in one place. The company believes savers should be given several years to locate forgotten pensions and consider voluntary consolidation before automatic transfers are introduced.
Lisa Picardo, Chief Business Officer UK at PensionBee, said: "Automatically consolidating millions of people's pension pots without their consent is not the answer to the small pots problem. It risks taking away choice, control and agency over where retirement savings are held and how they are managed, moving people's money into unfamiliar schemes, and creating further confusion through additional accounts, logins and apps."
Calls for clearer pension charges
PensionBee is also calling for pension providers to make charges easier for customers to understand and compare. It wants providers to display the annual cost of holding a pension in pounds and pence, alongside the percentage charged against the value of the pot. The company has highlighted findings from the Financial Conduct Authority's Financial Lives Survey showing that 57 per cent of adults with a defined contribution pension do not know they pay fees.
It also wants providers to display a prominent Value for Money rating to help savers assess whether their pension arrangements offer reasonable value. Ms Picardo added: "Crucially, the proposals do not address the underlying problem of excessive charges eroding the value of small pension pots. The Government should tackle the problem at its source by introducing a £5,000 de minimis threshold, banning flat fees on pension pots below this level."
She also warned that many people with small, inactive workplace pensions may be unaware of the charges being deducted from their savings. PensionBee maintains that improving transparency and protecting smaller pension pots should be priorities before the UK Government proceeds with automatic consolidation.