A reader who has attended three job interviews in two months has found that every salary offered was lower than his current pay, prompting careers expert James Innes to advise on when a pay cut might make sense.
Martin, from Coventry, wrote to the Jobs Guru column explaining that he has been invited to three interviews recently, and each time the salary turned out to be less than his current earnings, in one case by almost £7,000. He is not applying for wildly different roles, saying they all look about the same level as his current position. His employer pays reasonably well, but there is little chance of promotion, and his twice-weekly commute is wearing him down.
Considering a Lower-Paying Role
One of the lower-paid jobs sounded genuinely interesting and offered training he does not currently receive. Part of him thinks it would be foolish to accept less, and he cannot help seeing it as an insult, as though employers or recruiters are undervaluing him. Another part wonders whether he is too hung up on money, and when, if ever, taking a step backwards makes sense.
Innes advises against viewing the situation as an insult, but acknowledges it is annoying. He questions how Martin has reached three interviews without being told what the jobs pay, and stresses there is nothing rude about asking for the salary range before agreeing to an interview, as it wastes both parties' time if the money on offer would never be accepted.
Assessing the Full Package
Innes suggests that taking less might be possible if Martin is exceptionally well paid or if a job offers better prospects, a much shorter commute, or training he cannot get elsewhere. However, he warns that promises of progression cost an employer nothing, and advises asking what progression has looked like for other people.
He recommends deciding the lowest package Martin would actually accept and not attending interviews if the job cannot reach that figure. If it can, and it offers something his present job cannot, Innes would not call that moving backwards.
Calculating Commuting Costs
Innes also highlights the cost of commuting, noting that most people can say what they spend on petrol or train fares, but few value the time involved. He gives an example of spending an hour each way getting to work three days a week, which amounts to six hours before answering an email and well over 250 hours in a working year. Adding parking, lunches, work clothes and extra childcare can make commuting an expensive business.
He suggests that when comparing two jobs, workers should calculate the take-home pay for each, subtract the cost of each commute, and then consider the time. Once that is done, the lower-paid job may not be much of a pay cut after all.